What would be better, 4890 or 5770?

Discussion in 'Videocards - AMD Radeon' started by LostHH, Dec 7, 2009.

  1. loneknives

    loneknives Master Guru

    Messages:
    229
    Likes Received:
    0
    GPU:
    Galaxy gtx 670 GC
    crossfire 5770 ^^
     
  2. goodald

    goodald Member Guru

    Messages:
    100
    Likes Received:
    0
    GPU:
    580 Asus DCII
    I'm not sure why people are saying faster cpu's are needed at lower resolution.

    At lower resolutions you are just more likely to hit a point where your CPU speed is limiting you FPS. At this point, however, you're probably way over 60 MIN fps so what's the point.

    Counterstrike at 180fps is no different from counterstrike at 200fps.




    PSU.. A nice single rail PSU has always made the most sense to me; not having to worry how my rails are loaded (which affects efficiency) is a plus.

    PC power and cooling and Corsair both make good single rails, and there's more out there I'm sure.

    I have a PCP&P 750 quad that I got last year for about a hundred bucks... no complaints. Both Corsair and PC make lesser priced models
     
  3. Sever

    Sever Ancient Guru

    Messages:
    4,826
    Likes Received:
    0
    GPU:
    Galaxy 3GB 660TI
    cpu bottlenecks actually can be worse than that.

    when i had my old dual core 5600+, 4 gigs ddr2, and my 4670, games would run at 10-15fps at less than 1024x768, but they would run at 40-50fps at 1280x720, and 25-30fps at 1920x1080. no drivers were changed when i did this testing. as i upped the resolution, the reliance on my dual core decreased.

    but then again, the athlon x2 were pretty crappy.
     
  4. Mike Z

    Mike Z Master Guru

    Messages:
    773
    Likes Received:
    4
    GPU:
    GTX 670
    HEY ! I disagree. I don't think my Athlon X2 is crappy.
     

  5. LostHH

    LostHH Active Member

    Messages:
    89
    Likes Received:
    0
    GPU:
    XFX HD6950
    Well thanks for the replies guys, you've given me a lot of info to chew over but thanks to this post :

    I'm looking at an AMD based upgrade >_> Man I wish I could make up my mind. The price of the aforementioned AMD X4 955 is as mentioned, the same as the dual intel I was looking at.
    Can anyone recommend some mATX mid range/ decent quality motherboards for this chip please, I would be very grateful :)

    Edit - also, it seems to make sense what with AMD owning ATi so getting a system based on these techs says to me it would be more stable.
     
    Last edited: Dec 8, 2009
  6. Fahim

    Fahim Member Guru

    Messages:
    188
    Likes Received:
    0
    GPU:
    XFX RADEON HD 5850 1GB Bl
    Hello,

    I am using AMD Phenom 955 BE and the processor is very good for the price, and it is even cheaper now. You can get this motherboard which is good for the price and has all necessary features:

    http://www.overclockers.co.uk/showproduct.php?prodid=MB-198-GI&groupid=701&catid=5&subcat=1481

    As for the 4890 or 5770, i have both cards, have a look at this benchmark results:

    GIGABYTE RADEON HD 4890 1GB (850, 3900)
    XFX RADEON HD 5770 1GB (850, 4800)

    3DMark Vantage (1280 x 1024):

    HD 4890 - P10544 3DMarks
    HD 5770 - P9192 3DMarks

    Call Of Juarez Benchmark (1440 x 900, No AA):

    HD 4890 - 34.7 FPS (Min) / 150.9 FPS (Max) / 66.5 FPS (Avg.)
    HD 5770 - 31.2 FPS (Min) / 135.11 FPS (Max) / 62.8 FPS (Avg.)

    Call Of Juarez Benchmark (1440 x 900, 4x AA):

    HD 4890 - 25.4 FPS / 122.3 FPS / 56.0 FPS
    HD 5770 - 23.3 FPS / 102.6 FPS / 51.3 FPS

    Crysis (1440 x 900, Very High, DX10, Standard GPU Benchmark):

    HD 4890 - 37.17 FPS (No AA) / 31.78 FPS (4x AA)
    HD 5770 - 31.11 FPS (No AA) / 26.36 FPS (4x AA)

    Crysis (1440 x 900, Very High, DX10, Harbor Assault Benchmark):

    HD 4890 - 34.45 FPS (No AA) / 30.62 FPS (4x AA)
    HD 5770 - 30.21 FPS (No AA) / 25.77 FPS (4x AA)

    Unigine Heaven 1.0 (1440 x 900, 4x AF, DX10 / DX11)

    HD 4890 - 48.6 FPS (DX10), 38.9 FPS (DX10, 4x AA)
    HD 5770 - 48.5 FPS (DX11 No Tess), 30.0 FPS (DX11 Tess), 34.3 FPS (DX11, 4xAA, No Tess)

    Resident Evil 5 (1440 x 900, High, Motion Blur On)

    HD 4890 - 111.7 FPS
    HD 5770 - 78.9 FPS

    I tried benching at 4xAA, didn't work, gave me same result.

    FurMark 1.7.0 (1440 x 900)

    HD 4890 - 76 FPS (No AA) / 53 FPS (4x AA)
    HD 5770 - 94 FPS (No AA) / 35 FPS (4x AA)

    All bench done in a system with Phenom II X4 955 BE 3.20GHz, 8GB DD3-1600.
     
  7. LostHH

    LostHH Active Member

    Messages:
    89
    Likes Received:
    0
    GPU:
    XFX HD6950
    I must say, looking at those benchmarks I should get the 4890 for the extra FPS but being me, the impatient one, I ordered the 5770 about 2 hours ago lol
    So until I get paid this month, it shall have to put up with my current rig haha, not a great thing but I suppose it'll work unlike my Sapphire x1950.

    As for AMD, the prices really are good, am seriously looking into it as I was normally and Intel man (market leader etc)
    Although in hindsight, I think my case is mATX only, will have to check when I get home later but with that in mind I was looking at this :

    http://tinyurl.com/ybrz6cn

    Any thoughts from anyone?
     
    Last edited: Dec 8, 2009
  8. brando

    brando New Member

    Messages:
    2
    Likes Received:
    0
    GPU:
    Asus/ 4890/ 1024Mb
    I'm happy to stick with my 4890 for now. Watercooled, using an EK full-cover block, my highest temp during full-on gaming is 42*C. Likewise my 955BE (same loop) never exceeds 37 degrees. Gaming is a solid, stutter-free experience and that's all I ask.

    When and if Ati get their drivers sorted out I may try a high end 5xxx card but I'm in no rush.:)
     
  9. Fahim

    Fahim Member Guru

    Messages:
    188
    Likes Received:
    0
    GPU:
    XFX RADEON HD 5850 1GB Bl

    Motherboard looks ok, but it supports DDR2, do you really wanna go for DDR2 when the price is so high? Maybe you should go for DDR3, at least the memory will work on ur next upgrade...
     
  10. LostHH

    LostHH Active Member

    Messages:
    89
    Likes Received:
    0
    GPU:
    XFX HD6950

  11. Fahim

    Fahim Member Guru

    Messages:
    188
    Likes Received:
    0
    GPU:
    XFX RADEON HD 5850 1GB Bl
    Looks good....should be fine till your next upgrade....
     

Share This Page