Huh? :3eyes: You DO realize that it's all subjective, right? You DO realize that incredible sales DON'T MEAN THAT A GAME IS AUTOMATICALLY A MASTERPIECE, right? You DO realize you have EVERY RIGHT to disagree with any critic on the face of the planet about how "great" a game is, right? There are plenty of people on this PC forum who think the Halo games are over-hyped, overrated garbage. In fact, I'd say A LOT of PC gamers feel that way. Yet the Halo games got almost universal RAVE REVIEWS, they were declared ground-breaking masterpieces, and their sales were unbelievable (every Halo game out-sold Half-Life 2, let's put it that way). So does that mean every single person in this forum who thinks Halo is overrated is automatically wrong? Of course not. "Marley & Me" got way higher ticket sales than "Watchmen" at the box office, and they have about the same tomato-meter rating at RottenTomatoes. So that automatically means that "Watchmen" isn't a better movie than "Marley & Me"?? Anyone can think whatever they want about any game or movie or any other creative work, and if they can back up their opinion with good points of their own, even better. So let me make it more clear. Half-Life 2 wasn't just "disappointing", it SUCKED HARD. It was a worthless waste of time and I'm GENUINELY SORRY I even played it in the first place. It was a repetitive, boring, uninteresting, over-hyped, overrated piece of crap. In other words, it was a BAD GAME.